PayPal Splits Crypto Operations as NFL Deal Fails to Lift the Stock

The payments giant is executing a major structural overhaul while simultaneously chasing growth through high-profile sports sponsorship, yet Wall Street remains unconvinced on both fronts.

Crypto Business Gets Its Own Corporate Home

Since April 20, 2026, all of PayPal's digital asset activities have operated under a newly formed subsidiary called PayPal Digital, Inc. The transition happened automatically for users, with no action required on their part. By ring-fencing cryptocurrency services from traditional payment processing, management is drawing a clear line between two very different business lines. The Paxos Trust Company continues to handle portions of trading and custody as an external partner.

The strategic logic behind the move becomes clearer when examining the trajectory of PayPal's proprietary stablecoin. PayPal USD (PYUSD) has expanded to more than 70 markets since its debut on the Ethereum blockchain. The token now also runs on faster networks including Solana and Arbitrum, enabling near-instant settlement for merchants. Transaction costs have fallen by as much as 90 percent compared with international credit card processing.

A Blockbuster Sports Partnership

On the marketing front, PayPal has secured a multiyear deal as the official peer-to-peer payment partner of the National Football League. The arrangement places the PayPal app at the center of the NFL's fan economy, allowing users to split costs for tickets, concessions, and merchandise. To drive adoption, the company is running sweepstakes with prize pools of up to $1 million throughout the season.

The reach is substantial. Venmo, PayPal's subsidiary, connects a three-digit million user base in the United States alone. These users can now share payment links via text or email within the NFL ecosystem. Global peer-to-peer transaction volume across both apps rose seven percent last year, and with multiple international NFL games scheduled for 2026, management sees an opportunity to accelerate that growth further.

Analysts Remain on the Sidelines

Despite the NFL deal generating initial buzz, the stock quickly gave back its gains. PayPal shares currently trade at €42.55, roughly 37 percent below their 52-week high of €67.50. The year-to-date decline stands at about 14 percent.

Of more than 40 analyst ratings tracked, only a small minority recommend buying the stock. The majority advise holding. Mizuho recently downgraded PayPal to "Neutral" with a price target of $50, citing intensifying competition from X in the peer-to-peer payments space. That pressure is weighing on Venmo, which has been a key growth driver for the company.

The competitive landscape is only getting tougher. Apple Pay and Block's Cash App are aggressively chasing market share in branded checkout. Meanwhile, American Express is expanding its role as the NFL's official credit card partner starting next season, potentially diluting the exclusivity of PayPal's positioning.

Cash Returns Meet Earnings Caution

PayPal is not sitting idle. The company has authorized $6 billion in share buybacks for 2026, representing roughly 14 percent of its current market capitalization. That firepower comes courtesy of a strong balance sheet: free cash flow reached $5.56 billion last year, while revenue climbed four percent to just over $33 billion.

Yet the outlook for the current year is cautious at best. Management expects adjusted earnings per share to either stagnate or decline slightly. The next major test comes on May 5, when PayPal reports first-quarter results. Investors will be looking for concrete evidence that the crypto restructuring, cost discipline, and the NFL partnership are translating into margin stability.

Incoming CEO Enrique Lores faces the challenge of recapturing market share. He is betting heavily on artificial intelligence: according to the Evident AI Index 2026, PayPal employs more AI talent than any other company in its sector. Partnerships with Google and OpenAI are expected to measurably improve user engagement in the coming months. Whether that will be enough to reverse the stock's downward trajectory remains an open question.

Ad

PayPal Stock: New Analysis - 25 April

Fresh PayPal information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.

Read our updated PayPal analysis...

Ad

PayPal Splits Crypto Operations as NFL Deal Fails to Lift the Stock: New Analysis - 25 April

Fresh PayPal Splits Crypto Operations as NFL Deal Fails to Lift the information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.

Read our updated PayPal Splits Crypto Operations as NFL Deal Fails to Lift the analysis...